Chronicles of a First Year Teacher: Your Mom's So Dumb, She Flunked Head Start
I recently collected a book report assignment and a weekly free write final draft. Here are three interesting pieces of student work that I got back:
Please read the following passage from a book report on Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry:
...It is about an African American family that struggle [sic] through racism. They struggle to get money, food, and clothes to shelter their family. The reason for this is because Taylor writes not with rancor or bitterness of indignities but with pride, strength, and respect for humanity. This book is...
Can you pick out the sentence that doesn't quite fit? The author has had questionable sentences before, but this one was enough for me to actually Google the phrase. It turns out that the quote is from none other than the New York Times review of the book, which is quoted on virtually every online book vendor's site. In response, I decided to make rancor one of my vocab words for this week and used the sentence in question for the weekly context clues sheet to see if she'd notice. She didn't say anything today, so tomorrow I'm going to give her the choice of rewriting the paper or taking a zero.
The next passage comes from a book report on Love Always Bites:
...JAKIRA AND TANYA JUST STARTED TALKING ABOUT STUFF AND THEY FOUND OUT THAT BOYS ARE WACK AND THAT THEY NEVER LAST LONG UNLESS THEY ARE JUST USING YOU FOR ONE OR MAYBE TWO REASONS.ONE REASON IS FOR SOMETHING TO BRAG ABOUT DURING TALK TIME WITH YOUR FRIENDS,AND THE OTHER IS FOR YOU KNOW WHAT ELSE BOYS AND MEN LIKE...[sic]
All I could do was underline the last part and write "OK." in the margin. Amazing.
This final piece is the best of all is the following piece, written by one of my most ... interesting students. It's supposed to be the final draft for one of the daily free writes that we do each day during the week. I give them topics that I hope make them think, but they often write on other topics, the worst of which was this:
Have you seen Christopher's teeth? Every teeth is thirty miles away. His skin is so burned, that in the night you couldn't see him three feet in front of you. Christopher's teeth are so butter that they actsually blind you. Christopher is so ugly that when he looked in the mirror his reflection said "may God be with you." Christopher is so dumb that if you ask him what the square root of sixteen he will say thirty-two. Christopher's mother is so fat that she needs two toilets to do her bisness. His mother is so dumb that she flunked head start. His dad's nose is so big he can hide the whole family in it. His clothes are so ragidy and tight, you think that he a crackhead supermodel. His sister is so retarted if you asked her to blow her nose she would play with her lips. His brother is so short by the time he get thirty he will be three foot four. I think his whole family jacked up. I'm gonna stop janking this man before he's had an ugly attack. [sic]
WTF, mate?

Subscribe










